Scorecard / Year 1 check-in
Year 1 overall grade
- Overall grade
- D+ (editorial judgement)
- Scope
- The locked scorecard: 11 promises agreed in November 2024
- Metric grades
- 6 B, 1 C, 1 D, 3 F
- Check-in
- Year 1, published ; archive entry recorded
- Agreed by
- Mike (Trump Hater) and Steve (Trump Lover)
The overall grade is the one recorded in the Year 1 check-in. Every grade is editorial judgement against the baselines and targets locked in November 2024.
Sources and limits
What the grades mean
- A: Target met or exceeded, plausibly attributable to administration policy.
- B: Target met or significant progress, with caveats (timing, attribution, method).
- C: Some progress but well short of target, or target met only because baseline was already near it.
- D: Minimal progress. The promise has effectively stalled.
- F: Broken promise. Worse than baseline, or the deadline has demonstrably passed.
Metric grades in the Year 1 check-in
- 1. Onshore Manufacturing: C
- 2. Trade Deficit with China: B
- 3. Violent Crime Reduction: B
- 4. Fentanyl Crisis: B
- 5. Energy Independence: D
- 6. Border Security: B
- 7. Healthcare Costs (Prescription Drugs): F
- 8. Government Efficiency (DOGE): F
- 9. GDP Growth: B
- 10. Productivity Boost: B
- 11. End the Ukraine War on Day 1: F
Limits
Archive note (Year 1): Recorded on 15/11/2026 from the Year 1 assessment published on 24/05/2026. Grades, figures and verdicts are as published that day, except two DOGE figures corrected on 15/11/2026: the verified share of DOGE's claim (published as about 30%) and the source of the $135 billion estimate (published as a CBS analysis). Source lists are as shown on the site on 15/11/2026, including links corrected or added after publication.
The locked register · The Year 1 check-in in full · Check-ins (JSON) · Register (JSON)
Dated corrections: Later evidence and method corrections to this archived assessment.
Receipt link: trumpscorecard.app/receipts/scorecard