Skip to content
Term: --%

Year One Report Card · Updated May 2026

One year in.
The receipts are filed.

Two Aussie cousins locked a fixed scorecard in November 2024, eleven measurable metrics plus the loudest promises on the record, set after the election was called but before he touched a thing. No moving the goalposts. Here is how the bloke is tracking, scored and sourced.

2026 midterms: Republicans lose Congress. Read the results and our top 10 sourced reasons, starting with Iran, tariffs and ICE.

Read the evidence. Pick your own grade. Take a receipt with you.

Since your last saved visit

Enable JavaScript to compare the saved figures on this device.

    Compares the scorecard, headline promises, latest approval, debt, golf count and economy observations. Stored only in this browser. Refresh dates alone do not count.

    Year One grade Check-in: 24 May 2026
    37%
    Saved source average checked 5 November 2026. 60% disapprove.
    -23
    Net approval in percentage points.
    —
    Days past the 21 January 2025 deadline to end the war.
    Source: scorecard framework locked Nov 2024.

    The overall D+ is editorial judgement, not a weighted average of the eleven grades. Several later evidence and comparison limits are documented in the dated corrections.

    Approval, saved observations

    Latest observation checked 5 November 2026
    Source: observed polling-aggregator averages via Wikipedia. Fetch dates are not poll fieldwork dates.

    The eleven metrics

    Open the locked register

    Recorded arithmetic progress to the agreed 2024 target, where a comparable percentage is available. N/A is not zero; separate target components are not averaged.

    The grades are archived editorial judgements, not a numerical composite. Progress percentages are omitted where the evidence is not comparable or targets have separate measures. See the agreed baselines, targets, dated corrections and sources.

    0%50%100% to target
    Sources: BEA, Federal Reserve, EIA, CDC, BLS, CBP, Treasury. Per-metric citations in methodology.

    01 The verdict

    Two wins, a pile of broken shit, and a trillion-dollar bar tab.

    He smashed two numbers we will concede through gritted teeth: border crossings and the China trade deficit. Almost everything transformational, ending Ukraine on day one, a trillion in DOGE savings, cheaper drugs, 500 miles of new wall, is buried in a drawer or flat broken. We grade it a D+, and we are being generous.

    02 Kept vs broken

    What he said. What actually happened.

    We picked the loudest promises and counted them, no spin. He delivered on a handful, pardoning January 6, killing the tip tax, gutting the federal workforce. The rest either failed, got quietly dropped, or blew the deadline while he was on a buggy.

    A couple of the kept ones are genuinely bad for the world. We said we would be objective. Credit where it is earned.

    Source: Trump Scorecard promise tracker, each item sourced on the page.

    Headline promises, year one

    Bullshit meter

    Reading: broken promises as a share of the headline promises we track. Editorial judgement, from the promise tracker. The needle's overshoot is a joke. The reading isn't.

    03 The eleven metrics

    The scorecard we locked before he was sworn in.

    Each metric is one specific promise with a number attached and a baseline agreed in 2024. Ordered worst to best by grade. The bar shows progress to target; the coloured chip is our grade. Notice the pattern: most of the green hit target on a trend that was already running before he showed up.

    The register has the promise, baseline and target we agreed for each one, the deadline we read into it, and every yearly check-in. Open any metric on the tracker pages for the full breakdown, sources, and the editorial that makes Steve's eye twitch.

    04 Approval underwater

    The honeymoon ended. The deficit in approval stayed.

    The saved series starts at 47% approval in January 2025 and shows disapproval ahead from February. Each month keeps the latest source reading we observed, not a calculated monthly mean. The current number is not the frozen Year 1 grade.

    05 No recovery

    Everyone's unpopular eventually. He got there faster and never climbed out.

    Historical benchmarks provide context, not a laboratory experiment. The dates are shown. Past presidents use their latest stored benchmark no later than Trump's current stage, while his reading comes from the live source average. Different pollsters and dates mean this is not an exact same-day ranking.

    Historical source: Gallup Presidential Job Approval Center. Trump's current figure is the polling-aggregator reading above.

    Job approval: dated historical benchmarks (%)

    304050

    06 The trillion-dollar tab

    He campaigned on slashing it. Here's the live tab instead.

    $40.55T

    National debt from the U.S. Treasury. Up $4.3 trillion since he took the oath, despite the DOGE "savings" fantasy.

    Saved Treasury observation: 3 November 2026. The latest dated observation loads with JavaScript.

    Source: U.S. Treasury, Debt to the Penny.

    Debt at inauguration, plus what he's added

    07 The tariff tax

    The tariff isn't paid by China. Funny, that.

    ~$900

    Yale Budget Lab, 9 November 2026: modelled annual household cost under current law, not a bill paid by every household. The February Supreme Court ruling concerned IEEPA tariffs, not every tariff authority.

    Sources: Yale Budget Lab, November model; SCOTUSblog.

    SCOTUS on the IEEPA tariffs

    6 justices: unlawful
    3 justices: dissent

    08 DOGE's vanishing savings

    Of examined DOGE contract-savings claims, under 5% materialised.

    <5%

    of the examined contract-savings claims materialised in POLITICO's 12 August 2025 analysis: roughly $1.4B against $32.7B examined. DOGE's broader July claim was $52.8B. A historical contract analysis, not a complete audit of DOGE or a verified deficit reduction.

    Source: POLITICO, 12 August 2025.

    DOGE contract-savings claims examined by POLITICO

    09 The golf habit

    The golf habit has its own data feed.

    147 confirmed golf days across 665 source-recorded days in office. That is a lot of golf. It is not a verified taxpayer bill, a count of rounds, or proof of where he played on any particular date.

    TrumpGolfTrack count through 15 November 2026, checked 16 November. A current travel-cost estimate and course breakdown are not verified.

    Source: TrumpGolfTrack.

    Share of days in office with a golf visit

    On a course
    No confirmed golf recorded

    · Methodology

    How we keep score.

    The framework was locked in November 2024, after the election was called but well before he put his hand on the bible. The baselines, the targets, the scoring legend, all agreed before he was sworn in. Mike writes the copy and calls Trump what he is. Steve fact-checks it and tells Mike when he has gone too far, which is rarely. Every claim links to a credible source.

    The agreed wording, baselines and targets are in the register. Full methodology and both bios live on the about page.